Gift box
The Little Black Box
Four of Tiffany's favorites this season, hand-picked and tied with a ribbon.
$24
Hand-crafted · Small batch · Generously stuffed
Cookies worth
dressing up for.
Thick, gooey, over-the-top gourmet cookies — baked to order and boxed like a little gift. Pick from this season's collection, or dream up something entirely your own.
- Pickup & local delivery
- 48 hr standard lead time
New
Ghost S'mores
The Collection
This season's menu
Every cookie is baked fresh for your order. Hover (or tap) a cookie to peek inside.
Gift box
The Signature Dozen
Twelve cookies — two of each flavor in the collection. Made for sharing (or not).
$68
The Signature
It's what's inside that counts.
Every Cookie Creation is built in layers: a thick, buttery dough wrapped around a molten center — cookie butter, Nutella, whole Oreos — then crowned with something irresistible on top.
- Real butter, real chocolate, no shortcuts
- Baked in small batches the day you pick up
- Boxed and ribboned, ready to gift
Custom Orders
Something made just for you.
Birthdays, showers, weddings, corporate gifting, game day — tell Tiffany what you're celebrating and she'll design a box to match.
- 01Request
Share your date, quantity and vision.
- 02Design & quote
Tiffany replies within 48 hours with ideas and pricing.
- 03Reserve
A deposit locks in your date on the calendar.
- 04Celebrate
Pick up or have it delivered, beautifully boxed.
Custom orders need at least 1 week notice · minimum one dozen.
Gallery
Fresh from the oven
Our Story
Hi, I'm Tiffany.
Moon River, wider than a mile…
Cookie Creations started the way the best things do — in a home kitchen, with a little too much butter and a lot of love. What began as treats for friends and family turned into a small-batch bakery built on one belief: a cookie should feel like an occasion.
Every order is baked by hand, stuffed generously, and boxed with the kind of care you'd give a gift. Because it is one.
xo, Tiffany
Good to know
Questions, answered
How far in advance should I order?
Collection orders need 48 hours. Custom orders need at least one week — popular dates (holidays, graduation season) book up fast, so earlier is always better.
Where do I pick up?
Pickup details and your time window are sent with your order confirmation. Local delivery is available within a limited radius for a flat fee.
How should I store my cookies?
Keep them in the box at room temperature for up to 3 days. For that fresh-baked gooey center, warm a cookie for 8–10 seconds in the microwave. They also freeze beautifully for up to a month.
Do you accommodate allergies?
All cookies are made in a home kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts and soy. We can't guarantee an allergen-free product, but please reach out — we're happy to talk options.
What payment methods do you accept?
Secure online checkout with all major cards, Apple Pay and Google Pay is coming soon. Custom orders are reserved with a deposit once your quote is approved.